People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I visited in the area for a week and it took me a couple days to find a bagel shop this good and I ate here 5-6 times. I personally loved they had egg everything, but also loved the French toast bagel. I also want to talk about some of the bad review. I met the cashier and while I understand the abrasiveness, I just took him as your everyday New Yorker, and never actually had a problem. I've also seen a couple complaints about the charges coming up one price and when you give a credit card it comes up higher. This is because all New York vendors say give a cash only price, but then if you pay with card you pay a extra percentage. I myself loved that I could get a sandwich, large snapple, and a 5-6 bagels to go and it cost less than 20 bucks. ”
“ 10/10 delicious sandwiches. They have a wide variety of options. We ate a cinnamon raisin bagel with Taylor ham (which they said is a breakfast ham) and cranberry cream cheese and chicken parm on a roll. The bagel flavors are on display next to the register. You order straight ahead and while they make your order you take your receipt to the counter on the left to pay. The service was friendly and fast. The portions are very large. The pictures are only half of each sandwich and they cut them for you so it’s easy to manage. Definitely recommend! ”
“ Honestly, hands down best breakfast spot in Chester to my experience! The service is amazing. Food is amazing. You HAVE to try their sausage, egg & cheese with maple butter #Chester #Breakfast #Food #Sausage #Restaurant #Foodie ”
“ EDIT - Since posting this, the bagels I get have been much more consistent with the amount of cream cheese, so I am changing this to a 5 star review. Thanks Bagel Girls I love Bagel Girls and come here probably 4 times a week and have considered writing a review just like this several times. Half the time I go, they put on so much cream cheese and its amazing, and the other half, like today, I get little to zero cream cheese. In the pictures I posted this is unacceptable for a bagel store to sell a bagel with cream cheese like this. Please remedy this as its made me consider going somewhere else. ”
“ I ordered from Bagel Girls for 2 breakfasts during a family reunion weekend in the area. Toni was very helpful during the whole process, from figuring out the menu, to deciding on amounts, to making changes based on changes in the group size. The buffet style hot food on Saturday was solid, especially the French toast. I got platters of mini muffins and pastries for Sunday. The quality and the quantity were what I expected. I would order from here again. ”
“ Best place in the area for bagels, fresh and FILLED with whatever you ask for. ”
“ Bagel girls cafe has the best bagels around Chester Ny. They make amazing egg sandwiches! They also have huge selection of treats like the original black and white cookies Every time I visit Chester we make sure to stop here! ”
“ Awesome breakfast sandwiches. Love the Tayler ham, egg, and cheese. This is the best bagel place in the Hudson valley. Delicious hazelnut coffee. ”
Menu
Chicken
Croissant
Tongue
Brisket
Hot Pastrami
About
Bagel Girls Cafe
Welcome to the delightful world of Bagel Girls Cafe, where the love for bagels meets the vibrant spirit of New York! Nestled in the charming town of Chester, NY, this café has quickly become a beloved go-to spot for breakfast aficionados and brunch lovers alike. With an inviting atmosphere and a menu brimming with mouth-watering options, Bagel Girls Cafe is transforming the way locals and visitors enjoy the quintessential New York bagel experience.
At Bagel Girls Cafe, you're greeted with an impressive selection of bagels handcrafted to perfection, offering everything from the classic egg everything to warm, toasty cinnamon raisin. Each bagel boasts a fresh, chewy texture that sets the stage for a variety of delectable toppings. Whether you're in the mood for a smoked salmon salad or an egg & cheese topped with rich maple butter, each dish is crafted with quality ingredients that will tantalize your taste buds.
Customer reviews paint a vivid picture of their culinary delights. Douglas Roberts, a frequent visitor, shared his excitement about their diverse menu, including the much-loved French toast bagel. It's not just the food that has customers coming back, but the friendly and engaging service that enhances the entire dining experience. With a few caveats regarding pricing and service nuances—common amongst New York establishments—guests appreciate the value offered at Bagel Girls Cafe, often walking away with a full meal for under twenty dollars.
The café doesn’t just stop at bagels. Their breakfast wraps and hearty omelettes are renowned for their generous portions and unique flavor combinations. For instance, the Mexican omelette and the vegan-friendly veggie & mushroom option serve as hearty, satisfying meals to start your day off right. Carmen K. Thomas remarked on the delightful variety of sandwiches available, pointing out that the friendly service pairs wonderfully with the fast, efficient food prep.
As you step inside, the display of bagel flavors visible next to the register will ignite your curiosity. The atmosphere feels wonderfully laid-back, beckoning you to indulge in a flavorful breakfast or comforting lunch. For those planning a larger gathering, Bagel Girls Cafe has you covered with customizable catering options that ensure your guests will be delighted.
This bustling café captures the essence of Chester's charm while serving up authentic New York bagels with a warm, personal touch. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Bagel Girls Cafe promises a satisfying culinary adventure that is too delicious to miss. Get ready to enjoy a slice of New York right in Chester, NY, at Bagel Girls Cafe!
Book a table